Hunting at Buffalo Mountain Ranch.

My father in law and I arrived at Buffalo Mountain Ranch on October 1st, the evening before opening day. He had hunted BMR for the past several years and always spoke highly about the quality of the deer, the hospitality of Tammy and Rick and the affordability of the whole package. Rick and I spent a few minutes talking about various options for stands and decided on “3 Flats.” Saturday morning, I saw a few does walking through a distant field and an elk wandering by the blind. My initial thought after not seeing anything within shooting range was to move. I resisted the urge and returned to “3 Flats” that evening. Early in the hunt, I saw more does in that distant field and was a bit concerned this hunt might end like the morning hunt. About 30 minutes later, a few does appeared at the feeder along with a young 4point. As the evening hunt was quickly coming to a close, “Quotes” entered stage-left. I knew I had to act quickly because I only had 5 minutes of light left. I think I used all 5 minutes waiting for him to get within 25 yards and quartering away. I felt like I made a good shot, but decided to go back to the lodge, eat dinner and maybe pick up a little tracking help. Tammy made some great elk burgers that evening but my mind was on the deer and not the food. I ate my burger within about 2 minutes and I’m fairly confident my “tracking help” was eating in slow motion. While eating dinner, I told Rick my story, described the direction “Quotes” was facing and where I hit him and Rick predicted where the deer would be laying. It’s hard to believe his prediction was within 20 yards of where we found Quotes. To me, that was one of many events that really demonstrated how much Rick knows about the ranch and the habits of these deer. All things considered (quality, price, Tammy and Rick), I don’t believe you can beat BMR and I can’t wait to come back. Thanks for what was not only my best buck with a bow, but my best buck ever. Brian Busenlehner

After over ten years of passing up shooter bucks…
Jay finally takes one.

The dim, but sufficient light of the miniature one-LED flashlight in my hand was just enough, together with the cloud-shrouded full moon’s glow, to see quite well the road before me as I cleared the fence and walked toward the food plot. At the end of the little road before me was what we call ”camp oaks”, a quarter-acre food plot which had two hunting stands for me to choose.  One was one of those clever new wire ground-blinds that Larry Yerger had invented, and had put on a number of the food plots around the ranch.  The other was a twelve-foot tripod positioned so that the hunter would be shrouded by the branches of a stately old live-oak tree, which stood within the food plot itself.  The stands had been strategically located on opposite sides of the feeder location, making the food plot very huntable in either of the prevailing wind directions seen at Buffalo Mountain Ranch during deer hunting season.  The breeze was favoring the tripod this morning, so as soon as I reached the food plot, I strode quickly across the narrow neck of the plot toward the large oak tree which hid the tripod.   Given the choice, I would rather hunt the more open tripod stands.  You have to be very still and quiet in those exposed stands, but they allow more light to reach me in the margins of the day, and thus I can see my pins earlier – and later. The crunch of acorns beneath my feet as I ducked under the outer limbs of the old oak tree was a reminder of the bumper crop of them which had been dropping all this fall.  The deer, elk, turkeys and bison at Buffalo Mountain Ranch had been extremely well fed, from not only the natural sources, but by the food plots and the many feeders throughout the ranch. Topping the ladder of the tripod stand, I flipped the back to the plastic seat into its upright position, and stepped carefully onto the platform.  With a careful turn, I slid silently into the comfortable curves of the seat. I swung the seat around to face the larger portion of the food plot, and the feeder.  Several large hooks had already been screwed into the large limbs of the oak tree which crossed just a foot or two to the right side of where I was seated.  I hung my Mathews Dren on one, and my fanny pack on another.  Within a minute, I donned my face mask, and my gloves.  I already put my release onto my wrist before leaving camp.  After plucking my “number one” arrow from the quiver, I slipped the nock securely onto the bowstring with a reassuring “tic”.  The small fingers of the Kazaway fall-away rest held the middle of the arrow securely in the other two dimensions, awaiting my draw.  With the preliminaries all now accomplished, I pulled the miniature light from my mouth, and as I twisted its head it went dark.  My eyes would now begin the process of adjusting to the ambient light. The full moon was still very high in the sky.  On the opposite side of the world from a full moon is the sun.  After doing some calculating, I figured I would be sitting here for about a half-hour before first light.  That’s fine.  This gave the woods time to settle down somewhat from the disturbance that I made while entering the area, and climbing the tripod.  When I knew that on this trip I would be hunting during the full moon, I was concerned.  Rick Worley, the Hunting Manager at Buffalo Mountain, had told me that the second rut was still in full swing, so maybe that full moon was not so much of a factor.  The problem was that the bigger bucks were just skirting the food plots during the day, coming by on the margins to scope-out any does which might be feeding.  That is fine with me, since I was really looking for an older “old maid” doe anyhow. I’m a meat hunter. I prefer to save the best “shooters” for the other hunters who come to the ranch for trophy hunts.  My eyes were adjusting, and the contrast of light and dark was becoming more pronounced.  I now could see the shapes of the leaves on the branches all around me clearly, and the food plot beyond.  I swung around slowly in the silent swivel seat, and surveyed the various shooting gaps cut into branches of the old oak tree.  Depending on how I leaned in the chair, I would be able to launch an arrow through any one of four narrow gaps between me and the food plot.  Visibility is a balancing effort, because you can have a stand where you can shoot everywhere (but be easily seen by the deer), or you can have a limited number of shooting lanes, and be screened well from the deer.  We have chosen to take the latter approach, since it gives the hunter the best chance at a good shot.  Following that pattern, the oak’s limbs were left largely intact, so that the hunter would be screened from the deer for almost every approach angle, but still allow a shot at the most likely places where deer would be crossing. We have learned this lesson the hard way.  Deer have been known to look up at the seats in tree stands to see if a hunter is present, spoiling the hunt.   Hidden stands and hidden hunters equals calmer deer.  I pulled my Dren down from the hook, slipped my left hand into the lanyard and onto the grip, and rested the bow upon my lap.  As I faced the shooting lanes, a gentle breeze was blowing toward me from the front left quarter.  That was what I had in mind, since the feeder was at my front right quarter.  A growing faint orange glow behind me told me that first light was only minutes away.  There was enough pink light reaching the food plot now for me to range some landmarks.  The far edge of the food plot through the left shooting lane was 47 yards.  The middle shooting lanes gave me a good shot at the approach to the feeder from the left, with a range of 20-40 yds.  The far right shooting lane gave me a good shot into the food plot to the right of the feeder, and ranged from 20 yards to well past my shooting abilities.  Leaning to one side, I could see clearly a couple of the legs of the feeder, and I ranged them.  29 yards.  The downward angle of the shot was gentle, and would only make an inch or so difference at that range.  I made a mental note to aim just a little low when the range was 30 yards.  The electric feeder spun out corn and high-protein feed, right on the morning schedule.  I knew that sound would be the “dinner bell” for at least some deer.  I sat up a little straighter in the seat, and began to look more intently at the margins of the plot for movement.  The sun had not begun to hit the ground, but it was good shooting light, as the action began.  I saw movement to my right, and turned my head slowly to see.  A nice 8-point buck was already twenty yards into the field, coming toward the center of the field from my right rear quarter.  He crossed directly downwind from me, and I expected him to bust me at any second.  He didn’t.  Maybe it was because he kept his head down, eating from the wheat that still remained in the field.  Maybe it was good scent control.  I don’t know.  Although it had been very dry for the last many weeks, the wheat in the food plots was still green, and alive.  Early rains had really brought it on.  The blades were four inches long, but had been trampled by the many deer which came to the food plot. But the buck was able to use his lips to pull the individual leaves off the ground and take a few bites for each step.  He wasn’t interested in does, just some good nutrition.  He was only twenty or so yards to my right.  His rack was well out past his ears, and was a symmetrical typical 4X4, but was not heavy.  Although he was a “shooter”, he was only a couple of years old, and I wanted him to grow.  In the next three years he will grow into a monster that I hope some happy hunter will take.  I had already passed up about six or more shooter bucks as large or larger than this guy in my two previous trips to the ranch this year, and this one would be added to that list.  I’ll take a buck, but I really just want to take a cull.  We have some amazing genetics, and with the great nutrition, we are seeing some awesome horns.  I watched this beautiful young buck for probably half an hour, as he worked his way slowly across the food plot, finally working his way near enough to the feeder to gather up some corn and high-protein feed that it had just scattered.  As that buck was turning to leave, another buck entered the food plot from about the same location the first buck had used.  This second buck was another 8-point, but with a body and rack that were smaller than the first deer.  Maybe this was a deer that was also two, but maybe even a year and a half.  Either way, this young guy was also destined for greatness.  I watched as the two bucks simply grazed slowly through the food plot.  No does came to the feeder.   I have passed up so many large shooter bucks (taking only photos for the website) over the years.  I would really rather have the other hunters take these animals.  I’m happy with a doe, or maybe a spike.  The two young bucks finally walked off the food plot and into the woods.  But I would not be alone very long.  Within another ten minutes after those bucks left the plot, I again saw movement.  This time the movement was directly upwind – from my left front.  I leaned forward to peer around one of the larger tree limbs that blocked my view from that angle.  When I did, what I saw made my heart stop.  A large buck was walking toward the food plot in a small clearing between the trees.  His head was up, and he was alert.  I sat up in a more “ready” position in the seat, and leaned forward to maintain visual contact with this bruiser.  I could see that he was a “4 by something” even before he got to the food plot.  His rack was high, wide, and heavy.  But one side looked odd.  Where his G3 should be on his left side was only a small bump, and he had no brow tine on that side, either.  But the right side of the rack was beautiful, with long tines, in a typical configuration.  That is when the discussion began. When a deer that is coming in doesn’t meet my personal “specifications”, but I am pretty sure there will be a shot opportunity, an internal conversation begins.  I have had such internal conversations – and failed to resolve the dilemma with a final “shoot-or-no-shoot” decision before the animal walks away and the opportunity is gone.  I have occasionally finally decided upon a “shoot” decision, and just as the bow is fully drawn, watch a step too many put the animal into the “one-that-got-away” category.  So, here is how my two “inner hunters” argued, regarding this particular buck:  On one hand, this is a great animal.  On the other hand, I would much rather that another hunter take him, and I would just rather have a spike or a doe for the food locker.  One the other hand, there are only a very few days left in the season, and the chances that this brute will present himself for another hunter to have a shot are few.  On the other hand, I am trying to take cull bucks.  On the other hand, we almost never see spikes any more.  So, the argument within me raged back and forth as a tennis match played out in slow motion, as the huge animal walked in a nonchalant manner over to the feeder.    There he stood, right in front of me, broadside, pretty much lined-up perfectly with one of the shooting lanes.  And with no leaves between me and the buck, I could take a very good close look at him.  Now the mental tennis match was playing itself out in hyper speed. He was probably four to six inches taller at the shoulder than either of the bucks I had just seen.  His neck was huge, well out past his head, and blended seamlessly with some well-muscled shoulders.  His muzzle was graying somewhat, and large floppy ears hung well inside his massive horns.  He was a little “pot bellied”, which also confirmed that he was an older deer.  “Ok” I told myself, “It’s time to make a decision.”  The buck was an older buck, and with the amazing nutrition that he had been provided at Buffalo Mountain Ranch this year, he should have been a ten-point or better.  He had mass, he had symmetry, but he was only an eight-point.  His rack on the left side was deficient.  He would never be more than an eight-point, and he would be breeding that genetic trait into more and more does if I let him walk. That final analysis left the ball squarely in the “shoot” side of the court, and I raised the bow to vertical.  The Tru-ball release found the string loop quickly, and in a single smooth draw I brought the bow to full readiness.  I noticed that the buck’s front feet were even with the middle of the two legs of the feeder.  The second (30-yard) pin was placed just a smidgeon low, and I began to check-off the remainder of the final items before the trigger would be pressed:  the buck was dead-perfect broadside; the buck’s head was up, and he was looking generally away from me; his near front leg was slightly forward, exposing the vitals; the light breeze was rattling the leaves just enough to mask (even if only a little bit) the sound of the string;  the range was known and verified.  My right index finger moved from behind the trigger to the front. I took a breath, let it half-out, then held… and I began the squeeze.  The second pin was as steady as a rock at about an inch low when I felt the string surge forward.  I saw the arrow fly for only an instant, and heard a loud, hollow, “thwack” as the arrow found its mark. He ran at a slow gallop off to my right, and stopped after just exiting the food plot.  He just stood broadside, presenting me with a view of the opposite side of the shot.  It wasn’t hard to see.  A four-inch circle of bright red blood on his side showed me the arrow’s exit.  I smiled.  It was a good shot.  For better than a minute, the buck stood there, looking back at the feeder and trying to see something to explain what had just happened.  Then he decided it was not a good idea to hang around.  He began to run off into the trees.  But he soon stumbled.  He was able to get back up to his feet once, but then immediately stumbled again, and rolled into a summersault.  He was within my vision the entire time, and I saw his final resting place. I glanced at my watch.  7:15 a.m.  I lay my bow back across my lap, took a deep breath, and leaned back in the seat.  I would sit here for another thirty minutes, to be sure that I would be walking upon a fully-expired deer. That half-hour passed faster than I thought it might.  I was occupied by looking at the beautiful high clouds, now glowing in the sunrise.  I enjoyed the smells of the morning, and the gentle kiss of the first light upon the food plot.  I thanked God for the opportunity to live in a free country, which has places like this ranch… where bow hunters can experience wonderful whitetail hunts as I had just done.  I thanked Him for the blessings that had been mine that morning, and for those I had experienced on a hundred similar hunts from my youth to today.  I would have meat in the locker, and a “cull” buck would be out of the herd.  Blessings were too many to count.  The buck weighed-in at 124 lbs (field dressed) and had an inside spread of 15 ½ inches.  Rick said this was a six or seven year-old buck, and an eight-point was all he would ever be.  He was glad I took him out of the herd.  We have some much better genetics in the herd and those better bucks should be doing the majority of the breeding.  The two missing tines had been broken in fights.  A fresh tear of over four inches divided the buck’s right ear down the middle.  Rick said he would score about 122 if the two broken tines were added back in. Yes, after better than ten years of just shooting does and spikes, I had decided to take a “shooter” buck.  The good news is that although this bruiser was indeed a “shooter”, he was in reality a “cull” buck for Buffalo Mountain Ranch.  As the “never-better-than-eight” bucks are eliminated, bucks like “Rakes” will be able to have a greater effect on the herd.  And on top of that, every year we are importing some very expensive bucks and does to add their great genetics the herd.  Soon, maybe even next year, hunters at Buffalo Mountain Ranch will be thinking about passing up bucks like this one because there are increasing opportunities at many more who are so much more magnificent.

Let me first thank Rick, Tammy, and Chili Pepper, ya’ll really make B.M.R. feel like being at home.
I would also like to stress the economic value of hunting at B.M.R.  For a 5 day hunt; including food, gas, processing fee for two deer, and taxidermist bill I still spent less than I would have on a lease, around the house. Figure in the amount of time needed to keep a lease (time is something I don’t have much of) and I came out way ahead. I took my first deer with a bow on my last afternoon hunt, a doe that stood broad- side at 20 yards just a little too long.  That would have been a great ending to my hunt, but it gets even better. The next morning Rick suggested a new area in a ground blind (I use to not like ground blinds) he had been right on the money so far, so I agreed. Between 7:00 and 7:30 “Mercury” walked out at about 50 yards turned and walked away – all the way down the road.  I tried grunting and an estrus bleat, but he never even twitched an ear.  He disappeared into the brush 100 yards away.  I felt like that was it and I would go home without a buck.  Not 15 minutes later “Mars” showed up right in the same spot “Mercury” had vanished.  He made the long slow walk up the road (seemed like an hour or two) coming straight towards me.  I came to full draw at about 40 yards thinking that he was going to walk right in front of me.  The buck held up and started feeding (my heart was pounding).  Then, I heard a sound I have come to hate.  A doe winded me from behind. The bucks head came up and I let an arrow go.  In the excitement I wasn’t sure of the shot.  I saw my arrow skip down the road I knew “Mars” had ducked, and I wasn’t sure.  After about 15 minutes I couldn’t stand it any longer, I got out of the blind to find my arrow.  There was decent blood on it so I went back to camp.  Tammy had made breakfast for everyone that morning.  It was a little easier to wait with biscuits and gravy in front of me.  After breakfast we loaded up and set out to track my deer.  It was a short tracking job, the buck laid down about 50 yards into the woods where Chili found him (great job).  My first buck with a bow – a 12 point, right around 140”.  The biggest deer I have ever shot at with anything.  I am hooked on bow hunting and Buffalo Mountain Ranch.

I arrived at BMR on Monday November 8th expecting to hunt until Wednesday the 10th.  After the first 3 hunts I was about as frustrated as any hunter can get. I had seen numerous pictures and videos that Rick and Tammy had at camp, but the deer did not want to cooperate and cross my path.  On my “final” hunt, Rick told me he thought there might be a hot doe down near sandy field.  I decided to put all my eggs in that basket.  I met Rick a little earlier than normal and he showed me where the tent was.  The morning started slow with me expecting the doe to show up in this field.  After seeing a young buck early in the morning, I did not have much action.  Around 9:30,  I was hanging my head and just happened to glance up to see a big mature eight point, named Warrior, about 80 yards out in the field.  Although he did not give me a shot, I was rejuvenated with that familiar hunting spirit.  Upon returning to camp, I asked Rick if I could stay one more day and see if I couldn’t get him into range.  Once again, Rick advised me to hunt sandy field with the hopes of that doe showing up.  I entered the tent around 3:00 that evening, and by 4:30 I had already seen 2 young bucks within 20 yards. The two bucks moseyed off into the brush not long after they came in. About 30 minutes passed.  I could here something moving from behind me. I glanced out the side window to see the doe I had been praying for about 30 yards away.  As she walked into the field, I could see “mac daddy freak nasty” (that is not what they have him named but that’s my name for him) walking right behind her.  The doe trotted out into the field with the buck right on her tail, I drew back and grunted to stop the buck.  Rather than stopping the deer picked up pace a little.  Back to the dumps my hopes went.  I just missed the best opportunity I have ever had at a monster buck.  Disappointed but full of hope I returned to camp with a story.  Again, Rick and I decided the morning hunt would take place at sandy field.  With just enough light to see outlines, I noticed deer out in the field.  He was there again giving me another chance. However there were 6 younger bucks and 1 mature buck called “Mister” in the field with them. Without enough light to range him, I decided my best opportunity would be to wait until I had enough daylight to get a trustworthy yardage.  Again, I watched this monster chase the doe up a trail and out of sight.  As about 30 minutes passed I watched every buck in the field walk up that same trail.  I then noticed the big mature eight I had seen the morning before, walking into the field and heading straight towards the trail.  After he disappeared into the brush, I decided my best opportunity would be to walk the trail the bucks did.  I stepped out of the tent to realize the wind was dead in my face and the ground was sand (hints sandy field) aiding my stealth.  I began to walk the trail. About 100 yards down the trail, I stepped into a small opening to see two bucks walking back towards me.  I crouched next to a cedar watching “Warrior” come down the trail towards me.  He stopped at what I call 20 yards (actually proves to be around 30) and turned broadside.  He looked at the other buck and I drew.  I put my 20 yard pin behind his shoulder and let it fly. My eyes did not see what I had expected. However, I saw the deer crash about 30 yards to my left. I walked to where the deer was standing and found my arrow broken, but with the sign of a hit.  I walked back to the field and made the call to Tammy and Rick.  When they arrived I explained the story.  We went back down the trail and found where the shot was made.  With Chili, Tammy’s tracking dog, leading the way we found the blood trail. After following the trail, it looked like Chili had other plans.  The tracking dog was leading Tammy away from the blood trail (that’s what Rick and I thought).  But, the next thing I heard was Tammy calling Rick. They had jumped the wounded “Warrior”.  Tammy could tell he was hit hard and could barely run.  We began sneaking through brush, only to hear the buck jump up and run a few yards.  After drawing my bow twice on the buck, we finally could see him laying down about 20 yards away under a cedar.  Rick told me to try to squeeze a shot through the brush and end the chase.  Desperate for redemption of the first shot, I took a couple extra deep breaths stuck the pin on him and let it fly.  After letting it go, I heard a few ticks and the thud every bow hunter longs to hear.  We could see the buck’s head fall to the ground.  Trying very hard not to let out a triumphant yell, I eased up to the deer.  Big Buck Down! What a hunt! In three days I felt every emotion possible to a hunter.  What a place to hunt.  I can’t thank Rick and Tammy enough. Although, the first of my trip did not go as expected, I could see my frustration in Rick’s face.  I could tell he was just as dedicated to put me on a trophy as I was to find one.  The whole Buffalo Mountain experience is phenomenal.  Camp is a great place to share past stories and see many of the trophy bucks that will create future stories.  Thank you so much, and I will see you in December.
Josh Helmstetler